Critique of Edward Feser's Five Proofs

Over the course of the oncoming weeks I am going to undertake a critique of some of the arguments presented by Edward Feser in his new book, Five Proofs of the Existence of God. Although the tone of these articles will be primarily critical the intent will be to further the project of Natural Theology by flagging up areas where further work is required. I also hope, in later entries, to give some indication of how a non-theist who is not beholden to contemporary ‘scientistic’ naturalism might reply.

First under discussion will be Feser's account of the PSR Cosmological Argument, or, as he terms it, the Rationalist Proof.